I will paraphrase the story that Elder Holland spoke on last October. Jesus Christ has repeadedly told his Apostles that he wasn't going to be with them physically present with them for very long. When Jesus crucified the Apostles were left alone. With Jesus Christ gone the Apostles didn't know what to do and all the Apostles turned to Peter, the senior Apostle, as to what to do. Here Elder Holland gives his "nonscriptural liberty in [his] portrayal of this exchange." "Peter said to his associates: "Bretheren, it has been a glorious three years. None of us could have imagined such a few short months ago the miracles we have seen and the divinity we have enjoyed. We have talked with, prayed with, and labored with the very son of God Himself. We have walked with Him and wept with Him, and on the night of that horrible ending, no one wept more bitterly than I. But that is over. He has finished the work, and he has risen from the tomb. He has worked out His salvation and ours. So you ask, 'What do we do now?' I don't know more to tell you than to return to your former life, rejoicing. I intend to go fishing." At least six of the ten remaining apostles were in agreement and went to there normal day to day lives.
So Peter and some of the others went back to fishing and they were having no success from the night before catching no fish. Jesus Christ appeared to them in his resurrected body, though they did not recognize him immediately. Jesus told them to cast the net on the right side of the ship and of course they received multiples of fish. Peter recognized his Savior and jumped out of the ship to meet Jesus. Now here is the point I want to focus on. Jesus after greeting Peter and the others, asked Peter, "Peter, do you love me more than you love all [these fish]?"(John 21:15) Peter readily replied "Yea, Lord; thou knowest that I love thee."(John 21:15) Jesus again asked Peter the same question. Peter, being a little confused answered the same reply a little hesitant this time. Again Jesus ask him the third time if Peter loved him more than the fish. Peter being really confused this time and maybe pondering this time seeking and honest confirmation in his heart to the answer he had readily given the first two time and he said yes, he loved him more than the fish.